api.snaplabs.js.org

[kRxZykRxZy]

• There is reasonable content on the page (see: No Content)
• I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions
• The site content can be seen at https://sl-api-v1.onrender.com

The site content is an api for https://snaplabs.js.org

[kRxZykRxZy]

This is returning an error but I don't understand it.

[nonnorm]

api.snaplabs should probably be up with the other As, not down with Snaplabs.

[MattIPv4]

@indus what's our position on API subdomains like this? The sunbdomain itself doesn't really pass the relevance check, but it is presumably providing responses needed for the parent domain, which is in theory related (though looking at the content, I'm not so sure really).

[MattIPv4]

Hi there!

❌ Your requested js.org subdomain must be inserted in alphabetical order in the cnames_active.js file before we can process your request. Please fix this. 🔤

[indus]

@indus what's our position on API subdomains like this? The sunbdomain itself doesn't really pass the relevance check, but it is presumably providing responses needed for the parent domain, which is in theory related (though looking at the content, I'm not so sure really).

@MattIPv4 Yes - I get the feeling that this is going in the wrong direktion or maybe startet wrong.

@kRxZykRxZy I've just noticed that you mentioned you may need multiple sub-subdomains (#10321).

At the same time, the relevance of your project to JavaScript developers or the broader JavaScript community is unclear to me. To be honest, when I reviewed your initial PR, I was in a hurry and mainly wanted to get it off my plate — though it turned out to be a rather slow and tedious process.

I’ve now taken another look at your page, but I still don’t see any clear connection to JavaScript. Could you please explain how your project relates to JavaScript in a way that would justify a js.org subdomain? Additionally, please describe your key audience and how they are connected to the JavaScript ecosystem.

addition: I've just merged two new projects - croot.js.org and nomini.js.org. I don’t know much about them, but I noticed that both pages mention “JavaScript” within the first 20 words. That suggests JavaScript matters to the creators and/or users of those projects.
I didn’t see a similar mention on your page at all. It might be the technology behind your project, but perhaps it’s not as central. Don’t get me wrong — I’m not saying “JavaScript” needs to appear in the first couple of sentences. I just happened to notice this while checking the other pages.

[kRxZykRxZy]

Hi there!

❌ Your requested js.org subdomain must be inserted in alphabetical order in the cnames_active.js file before we can process your request. Please fix this. 🔤

Ok

At the same time, the relevance of your project to JavaScript developers or the broader JavaScript community is unclear to me. To be honest, when I reviewed your initial PR, I was in a hurry and mainly wanted to get it off my plate — though it turned out to be a rather slow and tedious process.

I’ve now taken another look at your page, but I still don’t see any clear connection to JavaScript. Could you please explain how your project relates to JavaScript in a way that would justify a js.org subdomain? Additionally, please describe your key audience and how they are connected to the JavaScript ecosystem.

addition: I've just merged two new projects - croot.js.org and nomini.js.org. I don’t know much about them, but I noticed that both pages mention “JavaScript” within the first 20 words. That suggests JavaScript matters to the creators and/or users of those projects. I didn’t see a similar mention on your page at all. It might be the technology behind your project, but perhaps it’s not as central. Don’t get me wrong — I’m not saying “JavaScript” needs to appear in the first couple of sentences. I just happened to notice this while checking the other pages.

Overall SnapLabs is an online community platform that allows users to interact and make games out of blocks (and soon to come to make them out of code in vs-code web editor) and play them online using our cloud server. The SnapLabs site runs on a pure JS/JSX ecosystem, and so does the api (node.js). The js.org sites that mention "JavaScript" at the top are usually npm modules and snaplabs is not a npm module, Right now SnapLabs is in BetaV2 and had barely started advertising, in the next week the user charts will grow. If you want to remove snaplabs from js.org because it is not "too JS related" feel free to do so. I have other domains/sub-domains to use.